الگو:Source assess/توضیحات

This template creates a row in a source assessment table, corresponding to a single source being assessed with respect to the ویکی‌پدیا:سرشناسی. It is meant for use in ویکی‌پدیا:فرایند حذف. It must be enclosed in template {{source assess table}}.

The use of this template does not imply a final or consensus view of how any given source should be assessed. Though it may be used to summarize a developing consensus, it may also reflect the assessments of a single editor in the course of a discussion.

Background

The ویکی‌پدیا:سرشناسی is a general benchmark for assessing the presumed ویکی‌پدیا:سرشناسی of article topics. From the GNG: "If a topic has received significant coverage in ویکی‌پدیا:منابع معتبر that are ویکی‌پدیا:منابع مستقل of the subject, it is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article or list." The GNG and other guidelines expand on what is meant by "significant coverage", "reliability", and "independence".

This template (with {{source assess table}}) provides a visually clear means of presenting as assessment of sources against each of these three criteria, as well as an overall assessment derived from these criterion assessments.

Usage

{{ source_assess
| source   =     <!-- Source (link or citation template)               -->
| ind      =     <!-- y/n/-/? -->
| ind_just =     <!-- Justification re: independence                   -->
| rel      =     <!-- y/n/-/? -->
| rel_just =     <!-- Justification re: reliability                    -->
| sig      =     <!-- y/n/-/? -->
| sig_just =     <!-- Justification re: significance of coverage       -->
}}

Abbreviated:

{{Source assess
| src = 
| i =  | ij =     
| r =  | rj = 
| s =  | sj = 
}}

Argument	Purpose	Notes
source or src	The source being assessed	Should contain, at the very least, a link to the source being assessed; it may contain any other useful information, including {{citation}} templates.
ind or i (independence)	Discrete assessment of whether the source meets the criterion	Value Output Meaning "y" (or equivalent per template {{yesno}}) [justification] The source meets the criterion "n" (or equivalent per template {{yesno}}) [justification] The source does not meet the criterion "-" (hyphen) – [justification] The source partially meets the criterion "?" [justification] It has not been or cannot be determined whether the source meets the criterion [blank, or any other value] It has not been determined whether the source meets the criterion
rel or r (reliability)
sig or s (significance of coverage)
ind_just or ij	Justification for the corresponding assessment	These arguments are not strictly required, but their use is highly encouraged; deletion discussions are evaluated on the basis of well-supported arguments based on policy and guidelines.
rel_just or rj
sig_just or sj

"Overall" assessment

The template computes an overall summary assessment of the source, based on the three criteria. This overall assessment is determined as follows:

If...	Overall assessment	Meaning
All three criteria are "yes"		The source supports the case that the article meets GNG
All three criteria are "yes" or "–"	–	The source partially supports the case that the article meets GNG
Any of the criteria are "no"		The source does not support the case that the article meets GNG
Otherwise, any of the criteria are "?" or blank		The value of the source with respect to GNG has not been or cannot be determined

Example

{{ source assess table |
{{ source assess   <!-- first source -->
| source   = http://www.example_source1.com/doc1
| ind      = y | ind_just = 
| rel      = y | rel_just = The source is a noted book by a well-known author
| sig      = y | sig_just = The source discusses the subject directly and in detail
}}
{{ source assess   <!-- second source -->
| source   = http://www.example_source2.com/page1
| ind      = y | ind_just = 
| rel      = ? | rel_just = This is a self-published source, and the expertise of its author has not been established
| sig      =   | sig_just = 
}}
{{ source assess   <!-- third source -->
| source   = http://www.example_source3.com/file1
| ind      = y | ind_just = 
| rel      = y | rel_just = The source is a major newspaper
| sig      = - | sig_just = The article mentions the subject briefly, but does not offer much detail
}}
{{ source assess   <!-- fourth source -->
| source   = http://www.example_source4.org/doc1
| ind      = n | ind_just = The subject works for this publication
| rel      = y | rel_just = This publication is a highly cited scholarly journal
| sig      = y | sig_just = The article discusses the subject directly and in detail
}}
}}

ایجادشده با الگوهای {{source assess table}} و {{source assess}}

منبع	مستقل؟	معتبر؟	پوشش قابل توجه؟	ارزش کلی برای احراز معس
http://www.example_source1.com/doc1		The source is a noted book by a well-known author	The source discusses the subject directly and in detail
http://www.example_source2.com/page1		This is a self-published source, and the expertise of its author has not been established
http://www.example_source3.com/file1		The source is a major newspaper	– The article mentions the subject briefly, but does not offer much detail	—
http://www.example_source4.org/doc1	N The subject works for this publication	This publication is a highly cited scholarly journal	The article discusses the subject directly and in detail

See also

• {{ORGCRIT assess}} / {{ORGCRIT assess table}} – similar templates for assessing against the ویکی‌پدیا:سرشناسی (سازمان‌ها و شرکت‌ها)
• User:Abelmoschus Esculentus/SATG, a script for assisting users in creating a source assess table.